Decoder• Mar 23, 2026• 1:11:37Interview

Confronting the CEO of the AI company that impersonated me | Decoder

From Decoder

Shashir Mohotra•CEO, Superhuman

Executive Summary

Superhuman CEO Shashir Mohotra addresses the controversy and class-action lawsuit surrounding Grammarly's 'Expert Review' feature, which used authors' names without consent to generate AI suggestions.
Mohotra defends the feature as a form of attribution, not impersonation, but concedes it was a low-quality product and has since been shut down.
The conversation explores the deeply negative public perception of AI, with Mohotra attributing it to fears of job displacement, while the interviewer argues it stems from the technology's extractive nature.
Mohotra introduces Superhuman's new platform, Superhuman Go, which aims to create a new business model for creators by allowing them to build and sell their own AI agents with a 70/30 revenue split.

12 quotes

Concerns Raised

The ethical and legal risks of using individuals' names and likenesses in AI products without explicit consent.
AI's reputation as an extractive technology is creating significant public distrust that could hinder adoption.
The fundamental difficulty of an AI capturing the nuanced 'taste' and creative style of a human expert.
The potential for AI-generated suggestions attributed to real people to be low-quality or misrepresentative, causing reputational harm.

Opportunities Identified

Creating a platform (Superhuman Go) for creators to build and directly monetize specialized AI agents based on their expertise.
Leveraging a large existing user base (40M DAUs across 1M apps) to become the ubiquitous platform for AI assistants.
Shifting the creator economy business model away from advertising towards direct-to-consumer subscriptions for AI-powered services.

Key Themes

AI, Attribution, and Impersonation

The core of the episode is a tense debate over Superhuman's (formerly Grammarly) 'Expert Review' feature, which used public figures' names without permission. The CEO argues it was a form of attribution based on their public work, while critics, including the interviewer and a class-action lawsuit, label it as impersonation and a misuse of likeness.

This highlights a critical legal and ethical gray area for generative AI: how to properly credit source material and individuals without crossing the line into unauthorized endorsement or impersonation, a central challenge for the entire industry.

Public Perception and Trust in AI

The discussion delves into why AI currently has a net negative public perception. The CEO posits that the fear is primarily about job displacement, whereas the interviewer argues it's because AI is seen as purely extractive—scraping vast amounts of data without providing commensurate value or compensation to its sources.

Widespread public distrust is a major headwind for the AI industry. Understanding the root cause—be it economic anxiety or a sense of unfairness—is crucial for companies to build products that gain user acceptance and avoid regulatory backlash.

The Creator Economy in the AI Era

Mohotra outlines a vision for a new creator economy model that moves beyond advertising towards direct monetization. He pitches the new Superhuman Go platform as a tool for experts and creators to package their knowledge into AI agents that users can subscribe to, offering a 70/30 revenue split.

As generative AI threatens to devalue traditional creative work, new business models are essential. This represents a potential pathway for creators to leverage AI for direct monetization, turning their expertise into a scalable digital product.

Corporate Strategy and Crisis Management

The episode serves as a case study in managing a PR crisis in the AI space. Superhuman's response evolved from offering an opt-out, to killing the feature entirely, to the CEO appearing on a critical podcast to defend the company's position while also apologizing for the user experience.

This provides a real-world example of the reputational risks inherent in launching novel AI products. It demonstrates the difficult balance companies must strike between defending their technological approach and responding to public and creator outrage.

Get started free

Topics

AI ethics Impersonation Attribution Likeness rights Class-action lawsuit Superhuman Grammarly Superhuman Go Creator economy AI platforms AI agents Public perception of AI Crisis management Productivity software Shashir Mohotra

Processed Apr 3, 2026 yt-dlp + mlx-whisper + Gemini