How Leaders Lead with David Novak• Dec 4, 2025• 1:13:23Interview

She Sold Her Billion Dollar Company… Then Did What No One Expected

From How Leaders Lead with David Novak

Gregg Renfrew•Founder and CEO, Counter

Executive Summary

Gregg Renfrew, founder of Beauty Counter, recounts the company's journey from a $1 billion valuation and sale to a private equity firm to her subsequent termination.
After the company failed and went into foreclosure under new leadership, Renfrew made the dramatic decision to buy back the assets.
Faced with unsustainable legacy costs, she immediately shut down the company, laying off all staff, to pave the way for a leaner, more focused relaunch under the new name 'Counter'.
The new strategy involves a streamlined product line focusing on the top 50 SKUs, a more inclusive brand identity, and a rebuilt, cost-effective technology infrastructure.

9 quotes

Concerns Raised

The financial instability and debt that led to the original company's foreclosure.
The operational bloat and unsustainable technology costs inherited from the previous ownership.
The challenge of rebuilding brand trust and momentum after a public shutdown and mass layoffs.

Opportunities Identified

Relaunching the business with a lean, cost-effective operational and technology infrastructure.
Focusing on a streamlined, highly profitable product portfolio (the top 50 SKUs).
Leveraging the founder's authentic and compelling comeback story to re-engage the customer base.
Broadening the brand's appeal with the more inclusive name 'Counter'.

Key Themes

Founder Resilience and the Entrepreneurial Rollercoaster

Gregg Renfrew's story epitomizes the extreme highs and lows of entrepreneurship, from building a 'unicorn' company and achieving a billion-dollar exit to being fired from her own creation, only to buy it back from foreclosure. Her journey highlights the grit, perseverance, and emotional fortitude required to navigate public failure and attempt a second act.

This provides a powerful case study on leadership resilience, the psychological toll of business failure, and the conviction required to rebuild a brand from its ashes.

The Perils of Post-Acquisition Integration

The narrative serves as a cautionary tale about the clash between a founder's vision and a private equity owner's management style. The failure of Beauty Counter post-acquisition suggests a disconnect in strategy, operational understanding, and brand stewardship, leading to breached debt covenants and foreclosure.

This is highly relevant for founders considering an exit and for investors, highlighting the critical importance of aligning on long-term vision and operational strategy to avoid destroying brand value.

Crisis Leadership and Radical Turnaround Strategy

Upon reacquiring the company, Renfrew made the excruciating decision to shut it down completely to escape crippling legacy costs, particularly a multi-million dollar monthly tech spend. This 'death before rebirth' strategy involved laying off all employees without severance to give the new venture, Counter, a chance at survival with a clean slate.

This demonstrates a high-stakes approach to corporate turnarounds, where incremental changes are insufficient and a complete teardown is necessary to address fundamental structural and financial problems.

Strategic Brand and Product Realignment

The relaunch as 'Counter' involves a strategic pivot. The new name is more modern and inclusive, moving beyond the gendered term 'Beauty'. The business is also refocusing on its most profitable products, after discovering that the top 50 of 350 SKUs generated 91% of revenue.

This illustrates the importance of data-driven product strategy and brand evolution. By simplifying the product line and modernizing the brand, the company aims to improve profitability and broaden its market appeal.

Get started free

Topics

Founder Story Entrepreneurship Resilience Leadership Private Equity Acquisition Turnaround Strategy Crisis Management Brand Relaunch Beauty Industry Clean Beauty Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG)Supply Chain Ethics Corporate Governance Product Strategy

Processed Apr 6, 2026 yt-dlp + mlx-whisper + Gemini