The software sector has been 'obliterated' over the past year due to profound investor fears about the existential threat posed by generative AI, leading to a massive valuation collapse.
Key concerns are that AI drastically lowers the cost of software creation, erodes incumbents' pricing power, and enables large enterprises to build bespoke solutions or new AI-native companies to disintermediate established players.
Valuations have been cut in half, with the sector now trading at a significant discount to the S&P 500 for the first time in its history.
However, traditional software investors view this cheapness as a sign of trouble, not a buying opportunity.
Investors are in a 'wait-and-see' mode, as it's too early to identify which companies will successfully navigate the transition.
It will likely take at least a year for the winners and losers to become clear.
9 quotes
Concerns Raised
AI will erode the pricing power of incumbent software companies as the cost of creation plummets.
Large enterprises may use AI to build their own bespoke software, reducing the need for third-party vendors.
AI-native companies like OpenAI and Anthropic could disintermediate traditional software providers by offering solutions directly to end-users.
It is currently impossible to distinguish which companies will successfully adapt to the AI transition, making the entire sector a risky investment.
Opportunities Identified
The massive de-rating of the sector could create significant buying opportunities once the winners of the AI transition become clearer.
Incumbent companies with deep customer relationships and proprietary data moats (e.g., ServiceNow, Salesforce) are well-positioned to integrate AI and upsell new capabilities.
The shift towards capital returns through buybacks and dividends offers a new source of value for investors in a maturing sector.